Follow us


The first superior court judgment in a shareholder class action in Australia has been handed down by Justice Beach of the Federal Court of Australia in TPT Patrol Pty Ltd as trustee for Amies Superannuation Fund v Myer Holdings Ltd

The claim centred on statements made by Myer’s CEO during earnings calls with equity analysts and financial journalists on 11 September 2014. These calls took place at the time of Myer’s FY14 results announcement.

The Court found that from 21 November 2014 until March 2015, Myer breached its continuous disclosure obligations and engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct by failing to correct the 11 September 2014 representation at various intervals. However, the Court found that, because the market had already factored in a lower outlook, the company’s contraventions may not have caused any loss to shareholders.

This significant decision will have ramifications for listed companies in Australia.

A briefing paper setting out our observations and insights is now available, please click on the cover or download link above. A link to the decision is available here and some key points are below.

 

 

Our Class Action team is hosting a panel of Herbert Smith Freehills experts in Sydney on 6 November 2019 to explore the judgment and how it might impact Australian corporations, their Boards, the insurance industry and the broader community. Any inquiries in relation to the event please contact [email protected]. See below for three short videos that explore the main implications and takeaways.

Corporate Australia to be impacted by the Myer decision Partner Jason Betts explores the three key takeaways of the Myer decision.
Shareholder class actions: will the Myer decision open the floodgates? Senior Associate Christine Tran provides her perspective on the Myer decision, and discusses the standards corporations in Australia will have to apply in order to comply with their continuous disclosure obligations.
How the Myer decision provides guidance on quantifying loss Partner Ruth Overington considers the potential market impact of more class actions being commenced in the future. She also explores the Court’s guidance on how loss is proved and measured.

Key contacts

Jason Betts photo

Jason Betts

Partner, Global Co-Head of Class Actions, Sydney

Jason Betts
Ante Golem photo

Ante Golem

Partner and Joint Global Head of Construction & Infrastructure Disputes, Perth

Ante Golem
Damian Grave photo

Damian Grave

Partner, Melbourne

Damian Grave
Cameron Hanson photo

Cameron Hanson

Partner, Sydney

Cameron Hanson
Peter Holloway photo

Peter Holloway

Consultant, Melbourne

Peter Holloway
Ruth Overington photo

Ruth Overington

Partner, Melbourne

Ruth Overington
Gregg Rowan photo

Gregg Rowan

Partner, London

Gregg Rowan
Australia Brisbane Melbourne Perth Sydney Dispute Resolution Class Actions Jason Betts Ante Golem Damian Grave Cameron Hanson Peter Holloway Ruth Overington Gregg Rowan