Deferred prosecution agreements may be on their way and companies should be getting ready for this new way of enforcing corporate crime.
While the form of Australia’s DPA regime and extent of oversight might still be debated, the Australian Law Reform Commission’s final report on corporate criminal liability (which you can read about here), has clearly endorsed DPAs as a component of the enforcement landscape.
Drawing on insights from our Corporate Crime & Investigations and Class Actions teams, in this briefing we explore what DPAs mean for class action risks, and some issues companies need to manage in their response to emerging issues that may potentially end in a deferred prosecution outcome.
The introduction of a DPA process is no doubt a welcome addition to the prosecutor’s tool kit. Used well, it can promote efficiency and allow a corporate to accept wrongdoing with appropriate redress and remediation and continue to pursue its chosen business model. This is particularly the case in regulated industries or where government or state-entities are key customers of the corporate, where a criminal conviction could be fatal to that business model.
However, as part of any process of negotiating a DPA, corporates will need to take into account the increased class action risk from accepting the accompanying statement of facts and providing promoters of class actions with a clear advantage in preparing private claims. This will often be a finely balanced judgement, weighing up risks that are difficult to quantify. It may well need to be taken early in a process, based on imperfect information, and will involve, throughout, a need to show clear willingness to cooperate with the prosecutor.
Finally, in the course of any such litigation, care will need to be exercised in approaching the substantive defence of the claim. It will clearly be necessary to provide the court with context to the admitted facts, as well as updating them with any information which subsequently comes to light. But it will obviously be important to ensure that the conditions of the DPA are not disturbed by doing so.
The contents of this publication are for reference purposes only and may not be current as at the date of accessing this publication. They do not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Specific legal advice about your specific circumstances should always be sought separately before taking any action based on this publication.
© Herbert Smith Freehills 2021