A (somewhat) unquenchable demand for energy
Data centres, while underpinning digitalisation, are energy-intensive assets that, despite efficiency improvements in hardware and cooling, still require the consumption of a significant amount of electricity with a corresponding impact on carbon emissions. The International Energy Agency estimates that data centres account for between 1-1.5% of global electricity consumption, and together with data transmission networks are responsible for 1% of energy-related greenhouse gas emissions. In the UK, the National Grid Electricity System Operator estimates data centres currently use about 1% of UK electricity and predicts data centres will consume just under 6% of U.K. electricity by 2030.
Governments, investors, and data centre sponsors themselves are fast recognising the imperative of improving the sustainability and energy consumption outcomes of data centres. Emerging regulatory initiatives targeting this asset class highlight the tension between the digitalisation and decarbonisation megatrends represented by data centres but are also indicative of the opportunities to amplify both of these megatrends where sustainability and energy efficiency inform the growth and operation of data centres. The European Commission's Energy Efficiency Directive and Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive actively requires data centres across the EU with a minimum installed IT capacity to report emissions to meet new corporate sustainability reporting requirements as part of the EU's stated goal of making data centres climate neutral by 2030.
Globally, as part of COP28, a coalition of more than 60 countries (including the UK and the US) have signed up to the Global Cooling Pledge, a pledge to reduce energy emissions generated by refrigeration and the cooling sector by two-thirds by 2050. This will have significant implications for sustainability practices in the data centres market given that cooling the heat generated by the servers and equipment within data centres is critical to their operation, with such cooling accounting for approximately one third of a typical data centre’s total energy consumption.
For some of our broader insights into COP28 please see the HSF Insights COP28 hub.
Sustainability concerns in the data centre market has led to close consideration not only of increased energy efficiency but also to the use of renewable energy sources, such as solar and wind power, by data centre operators to reduce carbon emissions and meet sustainability requirements either directly or through the buying of power purchase agreements (PPAs) to offset the physical use of non-renewable energy with renewable energy. Operators of hyperscale data centres such as Google, Amazon, Meta and Microsoft are among the largest corporate purchasers of renewable energy in the world.
Opportunities for increasing energy efficiency in data centres have also been demonstrated in the significant waste and excess heat from data centres being applied toward district heating of commercial and residential buildings situated nearby. Last year in the UK, for example, it was announced that 10,000 new homes as well as commercial space in the London boroughs of Hammersmith and Fulham, Brent and Ealing will use waste heat from data centres for the provision of heating and hot water.
Key financing considerations for data centre debt
Data centres are capital intensive assets that require significant investment, whether to enable development, operation, or acquisition. Consequently, funding data centre growth requires access to bank debt and other financing sources. Innovative solutions are often needed, with financings tailored to the specific features of data centres whether that be the widely recognised intensive energy consumption of such assets discussed above or the unique terms of the contracts with offtakers.
No singular, uniform approach has developed toward the financing of data centres and to the considerations that debt investors will take into account; in practice these will inevitably be a function of the features of the transaction in question including the type of data centre asset (eg, hyperscale, colocation) and the stage of the lifecycle in which the data centre is at (ie, greenfield or brownfield). Accordingly, we have seen hybrid approaches toward the financing of data centres which are based on, and borrow from, features and techniques of traditional non-recourse project financing principles, real estate finance, infrastructure and junior holdco financing, securitisation, as well as leveraged financing structures. Some of the key considerations that will be relevant across these different financing structures are explored below.
The energy sustainability and related ESG credentials of the data centre asset are a key focus for debt financiers of such projects, as they are for equity investors. There is a significant opportunity in sustainability focused financing to continue to enable and incentivise quantifiable improvements in decarbonisation results for data centres (whether through utilisation of PPAs and renewable energy sources and including the deployment of digitalised technologies like artificial intelligence to assist with energy efficiency and costs in data centre operations). While a formalised framework for such sustainability and ESG matters specific to data centre financings has not yet developed in market practice, financiers would be concerned with the compliance and monitoring of such matters in connection with, and complementary to, the developing regulatory landscape in this sector, including the energy and environmental matters discussed earlier in this article. Certain metrics and sustainability-related performance indicators would feed into contractual reporting requirements and financing economics. Any margin ratchet for such sustainability-linked loans will be tied to the achievement of key performance indicators that perhaps, unsurprisingly so, given the energy and water intensive operations of data centres, are often concerned with energy efficiency and water usage, as well as other metrics associated with a reduction in carbon emissions such as use of renewable energy generation. Other than financing structures incorporating sustainability-linked loans, a green bond financing structure may also be considered where the data centres to be financed satisfy the relevant use of proceeds criteria and would in most cases include some degree of impact reporting for disclosure of the allocation of funds and the quantifiable improvement of ESG impact. Given the proven interface between the waste heat generated by data centres and heating distribution and district heating applications, we would expect this to be another potential sustainability-linked area that may develop in practice and to be of interest to financiers in structuring sustainability focused finance solutions for data centres.
In keeping with the infrastructure-like investment characteristics of data centres, the cash flows of data centre businesses usually depend on a small number of long-term, key revenue contracts or leases (and in the case of hyperscale data centres – a key revenue contract or lease with a single anchor customer/tenant). For most financiers, due diligence and some form of bankability analysis of these key revenue contracts (of matters such as the creditworthiness of the customer, and the rights of the customer to terminate or issue abatements to the sums otherwise payable to the data centre operator) will therefore be a key part of the credit profile for the financing, particularly in the case of financings tracking more closely a non-recourse or limited-recourse financing structure, where the cash flow generated by the project debt will be the exclusive means of debt repayment.
Where the financing is structured with a repayment profile featuring a balloon or bullet repayment on maturity of the financing, analysis of the term structure of the revenue contracts will be an important consideration for financiers given the refinancing risks of a balloon or bullet repayment. Similarly, key revenue contract terms expiring, or which will be subject to an option of extension, before debt maturity will be a credit risk that financiers would need to understand and require mitigation for.
As part of their security package, financiers are likely to expect (more so in a project finance-based context but also in some instances of leveraged finance) an assignment by way of security of rights of the borrower or obligor entity under the key revenue contracts. Financiers in a more non-recourse or limited-recourse financing are also likely to insist on a direct contractual relationship with the customers to the key revenue contracts through subordination, non-disturbance and attornment agreements (SNDAs) (functionally similar to tripartite agreements in project financings or non-disturbance agreements in real estate financings) by which the customer commits to its termination rights of the key revenue contract being subject to restrictions in favour of the financiers and by which financiers covenant to refrain from disturbing or interfering with the customer's use of the data centre.
It would not be uncommon for data centre sponsors to own the underlying land on which the data centre is based. In cases where the land is being rented from third parties such as local governments/authorities, financiers, particularly those in a structure based on project financing would be concerned with due diligence of the rights of termination and renewal rights under the lease and in a similar way as any key revenue contracts in a project financing structure, procuring a direct contractual relationship with the landlord through a tripartite agreement. The financiers may also expect to take security over the sponsors' interest in the land, by way of mortgage or mortgage of lease. In some real estate financing structures, an OpCo and PropCo structure among the obligors to the financing would see the credit risk and financing of the PropCo entity which owns the data centre itself and the interest in the land being segregated from the OpCo entity operating the day-to-day business of the data centre.
Given data centres are such energy-intensive consumers and beyond the resultant ESG considerations this creates power supply (and even more importantly, the uninterrupted continuity of such power supply) is critical to the delivery and operation of any data centre. Financiers, particularly those participating in project financing a greenfield data centre development, would be keen to understand the power supply contracts with third parties and how the data centre sponsor will attempt to limit their exposure to outages through any use of back-up generators and uninterruptible power supply systems, and in some cases, captive generators of renewable energy such as on-site wind or solar power. Financiers would also have an interest in the due diligence of the risks of abatement by the customers under the key revenue contracts for any outages in power, and associated risks.
Given the essential role of data centres in digitalisation and the exponential data requirements that underpin their growth, an important commercial goal often required by sponsors in data centre financings, particularly in more leveraged style financing structures, is the scope for the capacity of the data centre(s) being financed to be expanded and developed in the future. In addition to the permissibility for such transactions and activities to be undertaken under the financing, this may also be supported by the structuring of uncommitted accordion facilities to increase debt capacity to fund the capex for this purpose.
Specific financing structures
The most appropriate financing options (or combination of options) will vary with the sponsor's business, the exact nature of the data centre asset being financed and potentially the ESG and regulatory backdrop In addition to structures based at least in part on real estate financing and project financing for data centres in the greenfield development stage, some of the other specific structures seen in the market also include:
- leveraged infrastructure finance platforms (including junior holdco financing), in particular for operational data centre businesses with expanding key revenue contracts, with such financing focused on considerations of revenues and performance to date and including relatively higher leverage covenants with forward-looking adjusted EBITDA projections, lighter-touch covenant and security packages and flexibility for growth and expansion;
- funding using the capex lines in general corporate debt facilities as an option for some corporate borrowers;
- where a portfolio of data centres is being financed, the available financing options may be increased by cross-collateralisation. Options will also depend on what stage those data centres have reached – if for example a combination of greenfield and brownfield (sometimes called “yellowfield”) assets are being financed, the revenue generated by some assets could be used to service the overall financing; and
- asset-backed securitisations and similar trade receivables financings, under which asset-backed securities issued by the data centre operator are serviced by cash flows based on the regular payments due from data centre customers under key revenue contracts.
In conclusion, the momentum to both digitalise and decarbonise means that sustainability should, and will, be a major consideration for private capital investors and their financiers in a market for data centres that is only expected to expand in importance with the increasing demand for data-driven services. While the financing for data centres is expected to continue to require some flexibility as to features and to draw on considerations from different financing approaches without a singular set of principles, a function of the specific characteristics and credit profile of individual data centre businesses, sustainability-focused considerations in such transactions represent important opportunities for financiers to enable the move toward a carbon-neutral future in this sector.